Do Fish Feel Pain Like Humans When They Get Hooked and Die?

The questions on whether fish feel pain and whether we should consider their welfare have been a topic of debate for some time. Some people believe that fish cannot feel pain because their nervous systems are simple and that any suffering they experience is insignificant. Others believe that fish are capable of feeling pain and that we should consider their welfare in our actions.

There is growing evidence that fish are capable of feeling pain and suffering and that their welfare should be taken into consideration. Fish have neurons called nociceptors which are responsible for detecting potential harm, such as high temperatures, intense pressure, and corrosive chemicals. Fish also produce the same natural painkillers (called opioids) that mammals do, and their brain activity during injury is similar to that of other terrestrial vertebrates.

Feeling the Pain

There is also behavioral evidence that suggests fish are capable of consciously experiencing pain. In one study, researchers placed brightly colored Lego blocks into tanks containing rainbow trout. When the trout were injected with a painful substance called acetic acid, they were less likely to exhibit defensive behaviors, possibly because they were distracted by their suffering. In contrast, fish that were injected with both acid and morphine maintained their normal level of caution.

This suggests that the fish's behavior reflected their mental state, rather than just their physiology. There is a debate about whether or not fish can feel pain and if their welfare should be considered. Some people, like Bertie Armstrong, the head of the Scottish Fishermen's Federation, believe that fish do not feel pain in the same way as humans and that the idea of giving them welfare protections is "cranky." However, Victoria Braithwaite and other fish biologists from Penn State University have found evidence that fish can experience pain and suffering, similar to mammals and birds.

Even though we can't be sure that other animals experience pain exactly as humans do, we still need to give them more humane treatment and legal protection because they can suffer in different ways. More and more people are accepting that fish do feel pain although it may be different from how humans experience it.

Fish Natural Painkillers

On a biological perspective, fish have neurons called nociceptors, which detect potential harm and send electrical activity toward brain regions that are responsible for conscious sensory perception. Fish also produce natural painkillers and their brain activity during injury is similar to other animals. There is also behavioral evidence that fish are capable of consciously experiencing pain, as they exhibit different behaviors when they are experiencing pain or when they are given a substance that dulls the experience of pain. These findings suggest that fish can experience pain in a way that is similar to other animals.

In a study, researchers observed that rainbow trout that received injections of acetic acid in their lips exhibited behaviors that suggest they were in pain, such as rapid breathing and rubbing their lips against the sides of the tank. Fish injected with both acid and morphine also displayed some of these behaviors, but to a lesser extent, while fish injected with saline did not exhibit any abnormal behaviors. Lynne Sneddon, a biologist from the University of Liverpool, conducted experiments where fish were given the choice between two aquariums: one that was enriched and one that was barren.

The fish consistently preferred the enriched aquarium; but when some of the fish were injected with acid and the barren aquarium was flooded with a pain-numbing drug, they switched their preference and spent more time in the plain aquarium. When the drug was injected directly into the fish's bodies, they remained in the enriched aquarium even when they were in pain. These findings suggest that fish are capable of experiencing pain and that they will seek out ways to alleviate it when given the opportunity.

Fish Slaughter

There is now a significant amount of evidence that fish are capable of experiencing pain, and many biologists and veterinarians accept this. The American Veterinary Medical Association has published guidelines stating that fish should be afforded the same considerations as other animals when it comes to relief from pain. Despite this, the general public still has mixed views on whether or not fish can feel pain, and fish are not usually afforded the same legal protections as other animals in many countries. Fish are also not protected under the Animal Welfare Act in the United States.

However, fish are the most numerous vertebrates on Earth, with an estimated 10 to 100 billion farmed fish being killed globally each year and another one to three trillion being caught from the wild. There is a need for more humane methods of killing fish, especially in the wild, but these methods are often more expensive, which is a barrier to their adoption. In some countries, such as the United Kingdom and Norway, humane methods of slaughter for fish farms have been adopted. These methods involve rendering the fish unconscious through a blow to the head or strong electrical currents, and then bleeding them out or piercing their brains.

These methods aim to reduce the stress and panic experienced by fish during the slaughter process, and may also improve the quality of the fish meat. However, the vast majority of the trillions of fish slaughtered each year are killed in ways that may cause them significant pain. While some progress has been made in developing more humane methods of killing fish, the majority of fish are still slaughtered in ways that may cause them suffering.

Check out more news and information on Animals in Science Times.