Does Hot Water Freeze Faster Than Cold Water?

Many believe that cold water freezes faster than hot water. However, some claim otherwise.

Does Hot Water Freeze Faster Than Cold Water?

If you place two cups of water, one hot and one cold, in a freezer, you will probably think the colder water would freeze faster. However, notable figures, including Aristotle, René Descartes, and Sir Francis Bacon, noted that hot water might cool more quickly. Similarly, plumbers claim that hot water pipes break in extremely cold temperatures, whereas cold ones don't. However, physicists have debated whether this happens for over 50 years.

According to several sources, hot water freezes faster than cold water. This phenomenon is called the Mpemba effect, named after Erasto Mpemba.

The incident was discovered in the 1960s by Mpemba, who was only a teenager then. The Tanzanian teen and physicist Denis Osborne conducted the first systematic scientific studies.

The incident happened at Magamba Secondary School in Tanzania when Mpemba and his classmates made ice cream. There was limited space in the refrigerator, so Mpemba didn't wait for his boiled milk-and-sugar concoction to cool to room temperature, unlike his classmates, before placing it in the freezer. An hour and a half later, they were surprised that his mixture was frozen while the others remained slurry.

Although they could see the effect, subsequent tests could not produce the same outcome reliably. Various minute features can influence precision studies to study freezing, and researchers frequently struggle to know if they have considered all confounding factors.

The Mpemba effect has been observed in crystalline polymers, ice-like solids termed clathrate hydrates, and manganite crystals cooling in a magnetic field during the past few years as the debate over whether the effect exists in water rages on. Thanks to these new paths, researchers are gaining a glimpse into the complex dynamics of systems that are not in thermodynamic equilibrium.

According to a group of physicists modeling out-of-equilibrium systems, the Mpemba effect and its inverse - in which a cold substance heats up more quickly than a warm one- should occur in various materials. Recent research seems to support these theories.

Why Does Hot Water Freeze Faster?

To this day, the precise cause of this remains unknown. Many potential explanations for the impact have been put out. Still, the trials have not yet been able to definitively identify which, if any, of the suggested pathways is the most significant. While it's common to hear confident assertions that X is the root of the Mpemba effect, these assertions are typically based on conjecture or a selective examination of a few studies' supporting data.

Naturally, there is nothing wrong with making educated guesses about the nature of the universe or choosing which experimental findings to believe; the issue is that many people have different ideas about what X is.

Why hasn't contemporary science addressed this ostensibly straightforward query concerning cooling water? The main issue is that the experimental setup's various details, such as the container's size and shape, the refrigeration unit's size and shape, the amount of gas and impurities in the water, how the time of freezing is defined, and others, all have a significant impact on how long it takes water to freeze. Due to this sensitivity, experiments have usually agreed that the Mpemba effect exists, but they have disagreed about the circumstances under which it does and why it exists.

In conclusion, hot water does freeze more quickly than cold water in various situations. It has been observed to happen in several experiments and is not impossible.

However, despite frequent assertions from one source or another, the exact mechanism of this process is unknown. Although various mechanisms have been put forth, there is conflicting experimental evidence.

Check out more news and information on Physics & Math in Science Times.