A shocking case from Kentucky has raised serious concerns about how hospitals and organ donation networks decide when someone has died.
A whistleblower named Nyckoletta Martin, who used to work for Kentucky Organ Donor Affiliates (KODA), shared details of the incident in a letter to the US House of Representatives Energy and Commerce Committee.
The case involves a 36-year-old man named Anthony Thomas "TJ" Hoover II. TJ was taken to Baptist Health Hospital in Richmond, Kentucky, after a heroin overdose. After he went into cardiac arrest, he was declared brain dead and removed from life support as part of his wishes to donate his organs.
However, things took a shocking turn during a procedure to check if TJ's heart could be used for a transplant. TJ suddenly woke up and started moving on the operating table, which caused panic among the medical staff.
Surgeon Halts Organ Donation Amid Signs of Life
Martin told National Public Radio (NPR) that TJ was showing signs of life during tests meant to check if his heart was fit for donation. She described how TJ was "thrashing around on the table."
TJ's sister, Donna Rhorer, was with him and remembered seeing his eyes open as he was being taken into surgery. Staff told the family that these movements were normal reflexes. But when TJ began crying and moving more wildly on the table, the doctors became worried.
In response to the signs that TJ might not be brain dead, the surgeon decided to stop the procedure, saying, "I'm done. I don't want to be involved."
This decision has sparked debates about the rules used to decide when someone is truly dead before organ donation.
TJ is now alive and recovering, though he has speech and memory problems. The federal Health Resources and Services Administration is investigating the case.
KODA explained that when a patient's condition improves or they don't die within the expected time frame, the family is informed, and the patient stays in the hospital.
This case has raised important concerns about how doctors determine brain death. Doctors usually use a test called an electroencephalogram to check for brain activity. If the rules for declaring death are too strict or too loose, it can lead to dangerous mistakes.
Martin shared her fear, saying, "Everyone's biggest nightmare, right? Being alive during surgery and knowing someone would cut you up and remove your body parts? That's horrifying."
The Kentucky Attorney General and other federal agencies are now working to improve organ donation rules to prevent cases like this from happening again.
