Gas Flares Producing Five Times Methane Versus Hydrocarbon, Causing Climate Problems, Study Finds

Based on a study, the oil industry's method of burning undesired methane is less powerful than originally expected, resulting in new estimates for greenhouse gas emissions in the United States which are almost five times higher than prior figures.

The scientists determined that the procedure, defined as flaring, typically does not thoroughly burn methane, a strong heat-trapping gas that is usually a byproduct of oil extraction, in a study of the three main oil and gas basins in the United States. And, in many situations, flares are burnt and not rekindled, allowing all of the methane to flee into the sky.

Enhancing performance and assuring that all flares remain lit might generate yearly emissions savings in the United States corresponding to removing roughly 3 million vehicles from the road, according to the researchers.

"Flares have been a bit 'out of sight, out of mind,'" said Eric A. Kort, an atmospheric scientist at the University of Michigan, one of the scientists. "However, they are more significant for the climate than we expected," Kort added.

Gas Flares Competence

Neither industry nor the administration in the United States considered that the flares functioned at 98 percent competence. Nonetheless, numerous studies have proven that this may be overly optimistic, according to Genevieve Plant, an atmospheric scientist at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor.

Plant and her collaborators launched planes to analyze air over upwards of 300 flares in North Dakota's Bakken Basin and Texas' Permian and Eagle Ford basins, which combined account for more than 80% of the country's flaring. They have been subjected to various forms of five times more unburned methane than most have previously been calculated.

That reduction from 98 to 91 percent accuracy may sound little, but the repercussions are significant, as per Dan Cusworth, an atmospheric scientist at the University of Arizona in Tucson who wasn't even involved in the study. "Any percentage that is in the methane phase rather than the CO2 portion is far more hazardous."

The majority of the variance is due to non-burning flares. "We anticipated to see a variety of efficiency from flares, but we did not expect to see this many unlit flares," Plant adds. Around 3 and 5% of the flares were not responding at all. If those flames were lighted and burned at 98 percent power, they could clear approximately 13 million metric tons of carbon out of the atmosphere.

Plants producing gas releasing in the air.
Flares, like the ones here, burn off the natural gas emitted during oil and gas production, turning methane into less potent carbon dioxide. But the efficiency of these flares is much lower than previously thought. ALAN GORCHOV NEGRON/UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, YULIA CHEN/STANFORD UNIVERSITY

Unburned Methane Leaving Gas Flares

The wind might lead unburned methane to leave from flares, as can the presence of other gasses. Air, fluctuations in pressure difference, or issues with the spark plug can dim the flame; and if there is no frequent surveillance, flares can go illuminated for an extended duration.

Riley Duren, CEO of Carbon Mapper, a non-profit organization that will launch satellites in a year to detect potential sources of greenhouse gas emissions, said that the findings came as a complete surprise to those who have analyzed emissions from all of these oil and gas basins and are aware of the amount of flaring that actually happens.

Moreover, a thorough review conducted by the researchers suggests that wasteful flaring "is a more systemic issue," as per Dr. Duren, who was not part of the study.

There seems to be scant direct observable evidence of flaring efficiency everywhere on the planet, according to Dr. Duren. But, in general, "It's likely that combustion and flaring are less economic than predicted," he remarked in a statement from New York Times.

Check out more news and information on Environment & Climate on Science Times.

Join the Discussion

Recommended Stories

Real Time Analytics