Could Einstein Be Wrong? Theory of Gravity May Have Shortcomings in Explaining the Universe

hole
Pixabay / AlexAntropov86

While the popular theory of gravity, or general relativity, of Einstein boasts of success that has lasted for over a century, it does have its own theoretical shortcoming when it comes to explaining the Universe.

The Need For Deviation

The theory of gravity has only been tested in gravity that is weak. This is unlike other physical theories that describe the three other fundamental physics forces, namely, the strong, weak, and electromagnetic nuclear interactions.

General relativity's gravity deviations are not tested nor excluded anywhere in the Universe. Theoretical physicists think that deviation is necessary.

Einstein held that the Universe started with the Big Bang. There are other singularities that can be found within black holes. Within these massive cosmic mysteries, time and space become meaningless, while pressure and energy density end up becoming infinite. These show that the theory of Einstein fails there and that a more fundamental theory should replace it.

Quantum mechanics should be able to resolve singularities in spacetime. Quantum physics typically depends on two ideas, namely, the Heinsenberg uncertainty principle that holds that no one can know a certain quantity pair's value with absolute accuracy and that point particles do not have sense.

This is sufficient enough to understand that such pathologies should not be present in a theory that embraces quantum physics and general relativity. However, Einstein's theory ends up with deviations when attempts are made to mix quantum physics and general relativity.

This means that the general theory of relativity proposed by Einstein cannot be the utmost theory of gravity. Interestingly, Arthur Eddington began looking for alternatives shortly after Einstein's theory was introduced. Eddington is known for verifying the theory during the solar eclipse in 1919.

The theory of Einstein has lived through all the tests. The question now is where the general relativity deviations could be.

Understanding Gravity

With a century's worth of research, scientists have been gifted with the Λ-Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM) model. The symbol Λ refers to the cosmological constant of Einstein or a similar dark energy, which was introduced to explain cosmic expansion and acceleration. Though the model was found to fit cosmological data, it was found to be unsatisfactory and incomplete from a theoretical stance.

The model has also seen various observational tensions throughout the past five years. The constant of the Hubble, which notes the scale of distance and age across the Universe, can be gauged in the early Universe via cosmic microwave background. It can also be assessed in the late Universe via supernovae.

Both measurements offer results that are not compatible. The ΛCDM components also largely remain mysterious.

From an observational perspective, the most convincing reason for modified gravity would be the Universe's acceleration. The ΛCDM model postulates dark energy that is remarkably exotic and that has negative pressure that permeates through the Universe. However, the issue lies in the lack of physical justification of dark energy. The proposed dark energy alternative is the Λ cosmological constant, which calculations show should be huge. However, the constant Λ should be fine tuned into a small value for it to align with cosmic observations.

The idea of troubles surfacing from wrongly fitting cosmological data into the theory is an idea that has been gaining great popularity. This comes as the camp for dark energy stays vigorous.

This can be told by how the deviations of Einstein's theory are constrained by experiments in the solar systems.

Alternative Explanations

Literature pertaining to alternative gravity theories are widely present and have shown dramatic growth. In the last decades, theorists have been trying to see the physical consequences that result from other theories.

Recent gravitational wave detections have offered an approach to manage the physical class modifications that were allowed by Einstein gravity. However, there is a need to conduct further work and research.

Check out more news and information on Physics & Math in Science Times.

Join the Discussion

Recommended Stories

Real Time Analytics